EDIT 7320
Framing a Research
Problem
updated: 6-9-08
Outline for class discussion
1. Evangelism (motivation)
This activity opens the door to the
most practical professional research skill. Think of it as
Professional Problem Solving.
2. Unfortunately, haven't identified any readings that match exactly
what I'm talking about.
Elements found in:
- scientific method, exploring what is known (ex: magnets)
- reflective practice, reflective practitioner literature: think
about what is working and what's not and experiment with strategies
- action research (problem --> strategy --> measure -->
repeat)
- I-Search (getting down to a question; information sources beyond
the typical)
- Consider reading about any of these areas that you're not
familiar with.
2. As you start searching:
List topic
components and related literatures
- You have your interest area identified.
- Think deeply about the problem itself. Discuss it. Identify
its territory, components, characteristics.
- Talk to a person who has experienced this problem, or relive the
experience of interviewing that person.
- Use empathy to put yourself in the place of the person with the
problem. (Easy if it's you!)
- Do some preliminary reading (think I-Search again, no
note-taking); this will help you identify topic components.
- Example: multiple floor media center (inspired by one of
your interviews)(angles include:
disabled or injured patrons; ADA law; material shifting; fundraising;
and probably others)
3. Leads to proposing a research question
- questions appropriate for collecting data are usually sharpened
versions of what you'll do in this class
- will evolve a bit as your reading progresses, and perhaps even
more as methodology develops (next semester)
4. My suggestions
- unlikely that focus forms in a linear fashion
- Kuhlthau (2004) found anxiety at this stage; you do have a lot at
stake
- have a brainstorming session with colleagues toidentify
related topics (I often get ideas this way)
- make a concept map
- brainstorm possible sources of information; not necessarily
limited to peer-reviewed articles (make sure to consider the
credibility of each source - a topic for later)
- If you have a "trial balloon" idea - don't hesitate to float it
by me for assurance or guidance.
Reference
Kuhlthau,
C.C. (2004). Seeking meaning:
A process
approach to library and information services (2nd ed.).
Westport, Connecticut:
Libraries Unlimited.
7320 Home
| 7320
Assignments | WebCT
Fitzgerald
home
All rights reserved
http://it.coe.uga.edu/~mfitzger/7320/framing-res-problem.html
History: this file began life as a lesson for 6900. Summer 08: adapted
for 7320/Ed.S. context.
Updates: 6/9: changed "problem" to "interest area"
The content and
opinions expressed on this Web page do
not necessarily reflect the views of nor are they endorsed by the
University of Georgia or the University System of Georgia.