EDIT 6340
Final Project: Order
Assignment Description and Rubric

A Super Eight Assessment
Mode: Team preferred; Individual workable

Value: 25 points
updated 7-10-08



Purpose
To provide a realistic, collaborative opportunity to apply selection skills; to provide an opportunity to explore instructional materials in a specific subject area.  The following AASL competencies are expected: 1.3; 4.1; 4.2.

Overview
Choose an Annual Selection Target from your Selection Policy. For example, your PD&EP for this year may call for collection development in a particular area, like science, or to improve the fiction section, or to begin a DVD collection.  Assume that the Media Committee at your school has chosen this curricular area or collection portion for intensive development in the coming fiscal year. Choose an area that has the potential to demonstrate all the competencies reflected in this assignment.  Develop a consideration file of resources to support this developmental area.

Your job is to construct an order for these materials, and to defend your choices before the Media Committee. $2,500 of the budget has been earmarked for this purpose.  (If you have access to a similar but more authentic situation, we can work with it; please discuss with me.)
 
 

Procedure and Components

    1. Annual Selection Target and Rationale: choose one that has the potential of costing at least $2500. (It is possible to use more than one Target for this project, but it will be more difficult if you do.) In the Rationale, describe the reason for building up this area of the collection. Address your Rationale to your learning community, justifying your proposed purchases. It is essential that your Rationale include connections to the Media Center Philosophy, the School Mission (or Goals), the MC's Program Plan (PDEP), and student achievement (or learning).   Key themes in this rationale might include access to information, curriculum support, literacy, diversity, and intellectual freedom.  You need not be redundant, but your Rationale should cover most of these items. 
    2. Order list: Using the selection policies, selection tools, and procedures described in this class, compile a consideration file of potential resources. Make sure to use quality criteria appropriate to the topic and formats chosen. Provide an active link to the appropriate policies, or otherwise make it clear the criteria you are using. Submit vendor-ready lists of materials in the current order. include plenty of information about each item for adequate description: title, author, vendor, publication date, approximate price, classification, ISBN or other ordering number, and the specific reason(s) for buying each item. Although you will be spending $2500, you must use some procedure to insure against back order delays.  Make sure to provide for diversity of learners in some way - and be explicit about this purpose.  There should be some variety among formats.
    3. Presentation: Generate a presentation for your Media Committee in a suitable format (for example, a written "speech" or a Powerpoint presentation). Visualize the scenario of the meeting in which you formally present your order to obtain the approval of the Committee for the purchases. In your talk, you should clearly delineate your reasons for your selections, and reference the MC Philosophy. Specify how quality criteria were applied in the selection process (which means you must list the criteria or link to your Selection Policy), and how you guarded against self-censorship. Prepare your arguments as if you expect a great deal of opposition and skepticism. 
    4. Processing checklist: As you work, compose a checklist of all the steps you followed throughout this project - so that you can remember what you did when the time comes for you to do this again.  Include all steps from initial selection target through installing or unpacking the new items.  Address how you will promote the new items. 
Guidelines Submission Format
See here for more information
This assignment was adapted from an idea first developed by Julie Tallman.





Final Project Rubric
Tag List
Name(s)__________________________________________________


Criterion
Unacceptable
Acceptable

Contains all necessary components:

[]selection target
[]rationale
[]order list
[]presentation for media committee
[]processing checklist



Value: 5

[]Something missing:

[]Something incomplete:

[]Something does not match its definition

Deduct proportional points for missing items - some "weigh" more than others.
[]Contains all necessary components

[]Components are complete, meaning that every statement listed in the Assignment Description is honored.

[]Components reflect what they are defined to reflect




1.3 Access to Information

Value: 3
[]Little or no evidence of knowledge of issues related to access to information

[]No knowledge of the legal and ethical practices of the profession
[]Facilitates access to information in multiple formats aligned with learner diversity

[]Complies with and communicates the
legal and ethical codes of the profession (by exception - no tag required)

[]Supports intellectual freedom of users

[]Proactively avoids self-censorship
4.1
Managing Information Resources: Selecting, Organizing, Using


Value: 8
[]Little knowledge of accepted library policies, procedures and practices for selecting, organizing, and using information []Selects, analyzes, and evaluates resources using professional selection tools

[]Selects, analyzes, and evaluates  resources using evaluation criteria; articulates how criteria were applied

[]Arguments for purchases are supported and logical from the learning community's point of view

Purchases are justified by explicit connections to:
[]MC Philosophy or mission
[]School improvement or Mission/Goals
[]SLM Program Plan (PDEP) Goal
[link to the PDEP, or say in text 'this is one of our Goals' in addition to tag; if not - ded .25]
[]student learning or achievement


[]Organizes the LM facility and its collections (print, nonprint, and electronic) according to standard accepted practice: procedures seem complete, proper, and efficient

4.2
Managing Program Resources: Human, Financial, Physical


Value: 5

Fix:

Possible misconception/ weakness in this assignment – emphasis of overspending (to avoid back-ordering) but not enough emphasis on staying within budgeted amount overall. Will correct. No deduction.

[]Little knowledge of effective management policies, procedures and principles

[]Little knowledge of relationship of facility to program needs

[]Explicit management problem detected: __________________
Applies accepted management principles and practices that relate to personnel and financial issues:
[]Selection responsibility carried out by qualified personnel
[]Collaboration with Media Committee evident
[]Money budgeted and managed properly

[]Money was spent, with no danger of back orders. Math is correct; total provided.  Order provides adequate and accurate information for vendor's use.

[]New materials are promoted to the learning community.
Mechanics: presentation, grammar, spelling, quality of writing; formatting; organization; referencing

Value: 2
[]Errors frequently interrupt evaluator's ability to absorb content

[]Elements to be viewed by the community have embarrassing or unprofessional errors

[]Disorganized; hard to find required elements

[]Referencing problems or omissions
[]A few minor errors

[]Items meant for viewing by learners, co-workers, and parents are nearly perfect

[]Organized; headings included and tags applied

[]Clear

[]Consulted sources are referenced in APA 5th edition style
You self-assessed.

Value: 1
[]No
[]Rubric is missing.
[]Rubric has self-assessment
Reflection
Value: 1 (individually assessed)

Each team member privately reflections upon:
[]group process
[]personal contribution
[]individual learning
Total and Comments













Agendas | Syllabus | Assignments

Fitzgerald home

Expires 5-31-09.

Update record: 7/10/08: tweaked after spring08 projects. 4/9: changed submission details to electronic; 4/7: clarification re: date in consideration file; 3/17/08: highlights corresponding with tags; 1/9/08: removed Target column; changed Objective vocab to Target; removed internal and external redundancy; recalibrated numbers; articulated overly-general instructions; increased budget to $2500
6/11/07: added potential changes for 08
4/2/07: link to tags added. 2/12/07: rubric resize. 9/14/06: minor typos. Aug06: major revision.

All rights reserved
The content and opinions expressed on this Web page do not necessarily reflect the views of nor are they endorsed by the University of Georgia or the University System of Georgia.

http://it.coe.uga.edu/~mfitzger/6340/final-project.html