EDIT 6340
Instructional Material Review
Value: 15 points (5 points each)
updated 1-10-05

Purpose
Media specialists must work toward the academic success of all students, addressing the information needs of everyone in the learning community. One pillar enabling this responsibility is a balanced collection that reflects our multicultural society through diversity of format and content.  To pull off this difficult task, you will be expected to analyze, evaluate, and then carefully select items for your collection. You need several skills in order to select instructional materials:
This assignment helps you with the first 3 skills, and exposes you to the fourth (which you will apply in your Final Project).

Library media specialists will often have the opportunity and need to evaluate materials firsthand before purchase, although these informal reviews may never be written down.  Also, library media specialists may wish to contribute to professional magazines by reviewing materials and having these reviews published; there are never enough reviewers for the many items published each year.  Part of your challenge is keeping abreast with new materials. You can accomplish this through your connections with the larger library world - public, academic, and special libraries, and other information centers -  and through professional organizations and publications.
 

Task
Choose 3 items that upon first inspection might be suitable for a media center. These items should be of three different types or formats:
 


Types may overlap, but have at least one in each bulleted category.  For example, you might select a picture storybook, a video about geology, and an educational computer game to review.  You might choose items that would be suitable for your preferred aged range, or you may deliberately want to sample outside of your familiar age-group territory. Study the item, and form a professional opinion about its quality and the possible contribution it might make to a school’s instructional program.  You should also study several reviews published in school library journals or children's literature journals as examples (School Library Journal, Book Report, Hornbook, etc.).

 
After looking at instructional reviews from several sources, decide which journal's review format you would like to use for this assignment. Provide a sample review from the journal.  Then write reviews of your 3 materials, closely following the format you selected.    Follow the recommended word count for the journal.  Self-assess your reviews using the rubric below, and recruit one peer reviewer to evaluate each IMR.  (It's OK to edit after the peer reviewer has looked it over - provide first and second drafts, clearly labeling each. We will grade the last draft.)

Submission Details
Do all of these:


Evaluation Rubric

(print 6)


Assignment prepared by __________________________________
Journal format followed ________________________(Provide one sample review from this journal)
This IMR contains _____ (#) words; the journal I'm emulating has a limit of _____ words
This rubric completed by _________________________

 
Criterion
Low
Medium
High
Sample review provided; 
follows stated journal review format, including all components; provides explanation if something is missing
No, or none stated 
(0)
Mostly (.1-.9); deduct proportional to component Completely: 
Editor would be very happy. (1)
Did both you and a peer assess your work, each using this rubric? 
 
No (0)
Partly (.1-.9)
Yes (1)
Does the review make logical sense? 
Reasons for judgments are not given, or not well explained (0-.4)
Mostly (.5)
Yes (1)
Is it substantial and informative?
No (0) - doesn't give a good idea of resource
Several minor problems or one major problem (.1-.9)
Yes (1)
Is the review concise?  No (0) - it's too long (check journal guidelines) Spends too many words on summarizing, but is within limits (.3) Yes (.5)
Mechanics
(Punctuation, grammar, spelling, capitalization, etc.)
Standard: write these as if you plan to submit for publication; i.e.: aim for perfection.
If errors total to >.5, you must resubmit Deduct .1 per error Clean! (.5)
Total (maximum of 5 per review) . .  .
Comments
 
 
 
 
 

6340 Home Page | Agenda | Syllabus | Assignments
Fitzgerald Home | IT Home

Expires 5-31-05.
All rights reserved
http://it.coe.uga.edu/~mfitzger/6340/instructional-material-review.html